ADVERTISEMENT

New Year's Day CFP games.

I think our "NIL struggles" are exaggerated

We pay our guys. We don't bag drop on portal guys. I think it's a key difference. We might have to outbid for a guy or 2 eventually (OSU bringing in Howard, Downs, Judkins, etc were HUGE pulls, definitely weren't cheap), but THIS year, I've not seen any "can't miss" types.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LandoComando
Ebuka makes the catch Evan’s and Wallace couldnt
Wallace and Evans both made tough catches yesterday BTW. But they don't have Ebuka's or Smith's combination of size and speed.

I think Wallace and Evans are underrated. Wallace has become a tough possession receiver and Evans is a burner who can get behind defenses. No they're not on the same planet as Ohio State wideouts but they've improved. Like Allar, they just need to get more consistent.
 
We pay our guys. We don't bag drop on portal guys. I think it's a key difference. We might have to outbid for a guy or 2 eventually (OSU bringing in Howard, Downs, Judkins, etc were HUGE pulls, definitely weren't cheap), but THIS year, I've not seen any "can't miss" types.
I think we may have seen a few paycheck teams this year fail because some of the players were playing for the paycheck. I think Franklin is doing it the right way culture wise and we are finally catching up from our late start on NIL, which were the fault of Forde’s, and our state’s, late entry into and embrace of it.
 
Wallace and Evans both made tough catches yesterday BTW. But they don't have Ebuka's or Smith's combination of size and speed.

I think Wallace and Evans are underrated. Wallace has become a tough possession receiver and Evans is a burner who can get behind defenses. No they're not on the same planet as Ohio State wideouts but they've improved. Like Allar, they just need to get more consistent.
This is a very positive spin on guys that can't beat man coverage, can't read zone coverage and can't make contested catches. Then it turns into the blame Allar game for his receivers being subpar.
 
Yeah, I don't believe the estimates at all--good find--I'm skeptical
That’s the only recent citation I have so I am going with it. I do know that PSU prioritizes retention with NIL funds as per a recent article I posted. I am not sure we are equipped to get an elite portal acquisition based on funds and philosophy.
 
This is a very positive spin on guys that can't beat man coverage, can't read zone coverage and can't make contested catches. Then it turns into the blame Allar game for his receivers being subpar.

The problem is, they are top 20 team type guys and we're in the Final 4.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LandoComando
That’s the only recent citation I have so I am going with it. I do know that PSU prioritizes retention with NIL funds as per a recent article I posted. I am not sure we are equipped to get an elite portal acquisition based on funds and philosophy.
So I do believe we use it for retention over portal which is why the numbers are a better kept secret.
 
This is a very positive spin on guys that can't beat man coverage, can't read zone coverage and can't make contested catches. Then it turns into the blame Allar game for his receivers being subpar.
Like when Allar throws it behind and too high to a wide open Warren and...wait for it....it is the fault of our best ever all world tight end.
 
  • Like
Reactions: m.knox
Wallace and Evans both made tough catches yesterday BTW. But they don't have Ebuka's or Smith's combination of size and speed.

I think Wallace and Evans are underrated. Wallace has become a tough possession receiver and Evans is a burner who can get behind defenses. No they're not on the same planet as Ohio State wideouts but they've improved. Like Allar, they just need to get more consistent.
Are either Wallace or Evans as good as Johan Dotson, Parker Washington, Allen Robinson, Chris Godwin, etc.?

Just don't have a legit #1 WR.
 
So I do believe we use it for retention over portal which is why the numbers are a better kept secret.
I believe most NIL collectives are organized under a nonprofit status, which may make those numbers public. I’m sure we have lawyers or tax accountants on the board that may have more in-depth information on that subject.
 
We hyper-focus on Penn State because that's obviously the team we root for. If you look at other team fan boards, they complain as well. No quarterback or team is perfect. People will always complain, regardless.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mhlarch and mcpat
It feels like pre NIL, we always had an elite WR. Post, not so much.
I believe the elite wr’s are very expensive in the portal market. Based on our NIL approach at PSU, the only way we have an elite wr on the roster is if we recruit and develop an elite wr. You are right, pre-NIL we were doing well at that position.
 
Like when Allar throws it behind and too high to a wide open Warren and...wait for it....it is the fault of our best ever all world tight end.
It's not his fault. That was a bad throw. I said during the game it was a bad throw. It's still a ball "our best ever all world tight end" has to catch. And more often than not he does which is why I didn't complain about that or the TD he dropped at the end of the first half on a perfect ball. He's been great unlike the other receivers and gets a pass.
 
We definitely had a good shot to beat Oregon. Too bad they didn't show up in the first half to challenge OSU and see if Day would then pucker up in crunch time.
 
So this game proves Oregon didn’t belong in the playoff, right? Cause every team that lost in a blowout didn’t belong, we’ve been told thus far.
I think it shows why no one said Tennessee didn't belong
Oregon isn't SMU or Indiana who didn't beat a team with a pulse all year.
It's year one--not everyone is going to be on the same page. I'm thrilled that we had an easier path but I want to reward teams that actually schedule well.
 
Are either Wallace or Evans as good as Johan Dotson, Parker Washington, Allen Robinson, Chris Godwin, etc.?

Just don't have a legit #1 WR.

We could go round and round, chicken and egg. I think the wideouts get overblamed. Part of the reason there isn't more production from the wideouts is that PSU has the best TE in college football, a 6-6 guy who gets open and makes NFL catches. PSU has two tailbacks with very good receiver skills. And Allar is just inconsistent enough with his location that it's dangerous for PSU to target intermediate middle of the field if the receiver isn't totally wide open.

For sure if PSU had a Godwin or a Robinson that would be helpful. PSU hasn't recruited a really big time wideout in a really long time. Dotson and Washington were amazing by PSU's standards but they would have been backups for Ohio State because of speed/size.

I think it's best not to blame everybody but just see that they're all working hard and gradually improving together. It's kind of silly to blame Allar's problem on the wideouts when everybody can see Allar's trouble with his footwork and throwing accurately when he's under pressure. You can see it. He's working on it. Allar is the leader of the team but still has miles of room for improvement, and that's a good thing.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: LandoComando
We could go round and round, chicken and egg. I think the wideouts get overblamed. Part of the reason there isn't more production from the wideouts is that PSU has the best TE in college football, a 6-6 guy who gets open and makes NFL catches. PSU has two tailbacks with very good receiver skills. And Allar is just inconsistent enough with his location that it's dangerous for PSU to target intermediate middle of the field if the receiver isn't totally wide open.

I think it's best not to blame everybody but just see that they're all working hard and gradually improving together. It's kind of silly to blame Allar's problem on the wideouts when everybody can see Allar's trouble with his footwork and throwing accurately when he's under pressure. You can see it. He's working on it. Allar is the leader of the team but still has miles of room for improvement, and that's a good thing.
So which of the three dropped TDs did you have a problem with at the end of the first half
The perfect throw to Evans right shoulder that he dropped
The perfect throw to Wallace that he drooped
The perfect throw to Warren, that most NFL QBs can't make, that he dropped
Where is this "inconsistent" stuff coming from? Allar was 12th in the nation in completion percentage despite playing in a vertical passing game--he does get 10-15 free completions on screen and bubble passes like Gabriel for example.
The reality is Allar doesn't have the weapons needed and we still haven't added good enough weapons for next year but please keep blaming our best QB since Collins.
If people think I've been annoying before regarding Allar we're taking it to a whole new level after the nonsense the last 24 hours
 
Gabriel's taken 8 sacks so far today--twice what Allar took yesterday--he probably needs to come back for a couple more years since QBs should never take a sack
 
  • Like
Reactions: rrdd2021
So which of the three dropped TDs did you have a problem with at the end of the first half
The perfect throw to Evans right shoulder that he dropped
The perfect throw to Wallace that he drooped
The perfect throw to Warren, that most NFL QBs can't make, that he dropped
Where is this "inconsistent" stuff coming from? Allar was 12th in the nation in completion percentage despite playing in a vertical passing game--he does get 10-15 free completions on screen and bubble passes like Gabriel for example.
The reality is Allar doesn't have the weapons needed and we still haven't added good enough weapons for next year but please keep blaming our best QB since Collins.
If people think I've been annoying before regarding Allar we're taking it to a whole new level after the nonsense the last 24 hours
Missed an open Warren over the middle. Is Warren a weapon?
 
  • Like
Reactions: m.knox
Gabriel's taken 8 sacks so far today--twice what Allar took yesterday--he probably needs to come back for a couple more years since QBs should never take a sack
Since college football isn't about getting an education, what's wrong with a guy playing 10 or 15 years, with NIL as high as NFL wages?
 
Missed an open Warren over the middle. Is Warren a weapon?
Yes, like all QBs he missed a throw--and, even with that bad throw, (AGAIN BAD THROW), it was catchable and a ball an elite TE should bring in. I don't understand why you don't think Warren is supposed to bring that in. Still his worst throw of the day because if on target there's also YAC
 
Yes, Drew never makes a mistake, Mrs Allar.
I've told you about 13 times today he made a bad throw there and twice at the end of the first half made a mistake when he tried to run instead of getting rid of the ball forcing us to use timeouts. He also had the ill-advised throw across his ball trying to get the ball to Dawkins. He's not perfect--no one is.
 
Maybe if Gabriel comes back for a 9th year he'd win a title

Guy is what 28, 30? He's an interesting prospect though. He'll be a late round pick or a free agent. But in the right system he could be successful as an NFL QB. Great pocket sense, quick release, never seems to panic. I don't know about his arm but they can definitely make him a better thrower at the next level.
 
I think it's best not to blame everybody but just see that they're all working hard and gradually improving together. It's kind of silly to blame Allar's problem on the wideouts when everybody can see Allar's trouble with his footwork and throwing accurately when he's under pressure. You can see it. He's working on it. Allar is the leader of the team but still has miles of room for improvement, and that's a good thing.

Allar will sharpen up. Good thing he stayed another year.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT