Thoughts and input from the collective.
This is not intended a criticism by any stretch, but more as an "observation" that applies to both RBY and Brooks, and maybe a lesser extent Carter. To be fair I saw Nolf our most prolific pinner ever run into the same issue from time to time.
I would like to see the count of 12-14 point differential majors our guys have earned the past few years. There have been many more than a handful. It's a testament to the challenge of getting to that 15 point span with catch a release strategy. You can score 10 takedowns to none, and gain only a 10 point differential. This aspect of the scoring frustrates me in almost every dual, partially because we are the best takedown team in the nation most years.
I really despise seeing outclassed kids get rewarded the 1 point for getting 'released'. I have toyed with the thought of eliminating the 1 point escape entirely, but I think that brings in the potential for unintended consequences. Likewise a 3 point takedown is just a wee bit too much, granted 2 seems like not enough. Seeing one of our guys up 6-3 after 3 takedowns in the first, only to get sloppy, give up a TD and you are looking at an undeserving 6-5 match.
Net-net, the main point I am trying to make is getting to that 15 point differential with catch and release 'alone' in 7 minutes is a real challenge.
As a counter illustration, Spencer routinely techs guys in the first and second periods. A TD plus 3 quick 4 point turns gets you to 14 points, and the victim is still sitting at zero. Exposure is rightly so, properly rewarded. You rarely see Spencer playing catch and release for more than 2-3 takedowns max. He goes for blood the old fashioned way. His catch and release is more tilt, release the arm, tilt again, release the arm, rinse and repeat, and ultimately Iowa starts most Spencer led duals up 5-0 or 6-0. This might help explain why Spencer has tank problems in the 3rd. Conditioning aside I would guess his average 3rd period minutes per match is amongst the lowest in D1
Not everyone has the skill for a friggin automatic semi indefensible move like Spencer has, but on balance I would like to see our kids across the board ease off on the catch and release in the second period a bit and work for more turns. Just one 4 point NF would pull many more matches into more sure fire Tech territory. Likewise we will get more pins with this focus as well. Our guys can always return back to catch and release in the third period of needed.
Turning is a critical and important skill. Anyone not named Max Dean across our lineup, has some room for improvement with this skill.
Am I getting to greedy? Maybe just a little, but it seems that we value the takedown higher than does the scoreboard. I think this year's team to to bottom may well prove Cael's strongest ever. Nonetheless, I reminder just a bit back to the days of Zain, Nolf, Bo. Their places are secure on our all time pins list. I would love to see some modern challenges to those numbers, but or focus would need to change a bit to get there.