Sorry, there is no sympathy point here. Big weight cut is not unheard of. Jordan Boroughs walk around weight is near or over 200 lbs. Ever heard of him? Just admit that you were wrong (not the first time) and move on.
Sorry bud, but I won't be proven wrong until next year. Bookmark this and then bash me over the head with it in November 2025.
PS - we just had a poster today pontificate the merits of Barr going up to heavy down the road. Do I think that happens? Highly highly unlikely. Nonetheless, that poster must really ruffle your feathers.
Do I think Barr might rethink 184 after a full year at 197, for a variety of reasons, you bet.
Do I think Marisola has been anointed 197 next year? Pretty much, yes.
However, if Barr grows a little more, might he challenge for the spot? Quite possible.
I gained 45 lbs and 1" in first two years in college, anyone who thinks all kids are done growing at 18-20 isn't factual. My main point isn't entirely the 16 lbs needed to get back down to 184, but moreso he might change physiologically forcing himself to go up to 197 for a full year. What might have been a hard cut, might then become a cut that leaves him listless and far less competitive.
Would I pick Barr over Marisola for 197 in 2025, both on full feed? A very good question.
Honestly the talent is so good I would not be shocked by either outcome. However far fetched it sounds today, if Barr goes 197 this year, there is at least chance he stays there, Marisola or no.
So on balance, all of this speculation is irrelevant, excepting for Barr at 184 and Carter at 197 made more sense on paper to some extent. I think the real deciding factor was Carter obviously couldn't get big enough fast enough for 197. If today he is walking around at 190ish he would have been giving up 10-15 lbs in body mass to his top competition. That said - I think he would have won @197 anyway.