ADVERTISEMENT

OSU Rumors

It'd be in OSU's and Smith's best interests for OSU to put some concrete info out into the world so that the wrestling world isn't writing its own story in various message board threads. Seems wrong to hang Smith out to dry like this, no matter which direction they're going in.
 
I think this is wrong on a couple fronts.

1) OSU has incredible tradition, but have been complaining for years about a lack of resources from the athletic department. It's not comparable to PSU. They've made some recent committments, but I'm not sure it's considerably better than Cornell.

2) Cornell is arguably the best recruiting situation in wrestling. They are not beholden to 9.9. They have a strong modern tradition with a great local fanbase. It's close to several recruiting hot beds whereas OSU is only close to Oklahoma.

If I had to pick, I'd pick the Cornell job.
Help me out with the “not beholden to 9.9” (as they offer 0.0) and the “great local fanbase” that averages 450 fans per home dual (43rd in D1) to OkSt’s 4,631 per home dual (3rd in D1).

Cornell wrestles in a facility that seats just 900 and fills just half of it on average. That’s a hard sell to claim they have the stronger fanbase.
 
Last edited:
Cornell is a better job than Oklahoma State in wrestling like Gonzaga is a better job than North Carolina in college basketball.

The perfect fit means being a true threat at one every few years, the perfect fit at the other means you're a threat every year.
 
Cornell is a better job than Oklahoma State in wrestling like Gonzaga is a better job than North Carolina in college basketball.

The perfect fit means being a true threat at one every few years, the perfect fit at the other means you're a threat every year.
Did you just use basketball to explain wrestling on a wrestling forum? Just checking. ;)
 
Did you just use basketball to explain wrestling on a wrestling forum? Just checking. ;)
It's not a good analogy, either. It's more like coaching football at TCU vs coaching football at Nebraska. One is good now, the other has the history and I suppose the ability to potentially return to former glory but have been buried for a long time and are currently a long way from the top.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mcpat
It's a demotion unless the contract also stipulates he's the head coach in 1 year.

Otherwise, agreed, why would he even consider something like that?
Because his wife is from OK and that’s where they want to be.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Str8DBLz
Because his wife is from OK and that’s where they want to be.
Agreed -- if his contract states he'll be the head coach within a reasonable period of time.

Otherwise: "Honey, we're moving closer to your family but we'll likely have to leave them again in 1-2 years. I'll get less pay now, probably won't match today's salary after the 2nd move, and who knows where we'll end up" doesn't sound like a great sales pitch.

If merely being in OK were the goal, then he could've taken the Bixby HS job 2 years ago, that Ray Blake got.
 
It's not a good analogy, either. It's more like coaching football at TCU vs coaching football at Nebraska. One is good now, the other has the history and I suppose the ability to potentially return to former glory but have been buried for a long time and are currently a long way from the top.
I think a good analogy is Cornell vs Penn State in the 2000s before Cael. And the rumor was that Koll was coming before Cael through his hat in the ring.
 
Not to be too disrespectful, but how many years has Coach Smith disappointed out of the last 15? Not even talking win title , but win a team medal ? He’s been trash , sorry
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: baccafarmer
Not to be too disrespectful, but how many years has Coach Smith disappointed out of the last 15? Not even taking win title , but get on the team stand? He’s been trash , sorry
He seemed to be knocking in 2021 but candidly, COVID might have been the best thing to happen to him since it forcibly shortened his season which prevented the normal burnouts and injuries. They also benefitted big time from numerous things that year that made them appear a lot closer to PSU than they were.

1. The Lewallen - Heil fiasco
2. Sheets getting a MFF over Berge
3. Wittlake getting a MFF over Mekhi then getting Cam Amine instead of Alex Marinelli to keep going in consys
 
Not to be too disrespectful, but how many years has Coach Smith disappointed out of the last 15? Not even talking win title , but win a team medal ? He’s been trash , sorry
They were 3rd in 2021, 2019, and 2016 while they took 2nd in 2017. Not maybe up to their old standards but that’s not horrible. This past year was a disaster that’s for sure and I do think they should move on from Smith. If they are going to stay in the OSU coaching tree I think Pendleton is the best choice. He’s done a great job at Oregon State.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mcpat and Str8DBLz
The Finger Lakes Area is about as good as it gets 8 months a year.
Respectfully disagree. Spent 4 years there and winter was rough from November through March. Plus the 2nd half of October and 1st half of April weren't exactly great; June to August are nice.
Grew up in PA, for reference. If you grew up in Siberia then absolutely the Finger Lakes are awesome most of the year.
 
Is OSU the Notre Dame of wrestling?

They have great history. Unfortunately a lot of it is before WW2. More than half of OSUs championships came when they were still known as Oklahoma A&M.
 
They were 3rd in 2021, 2019, and 2016 while they took 2nd in 2017. Not maybe up to their old standards but that’s not horrible. This past year was a disaster that’s for sure and I do think they should move on from Smith. If they are going to stay in the OSU coaching tree I think Pendleton is the best choice. He’s done a great job at Oregon State.
This is a much better recent record than I realized. 4 podiums in the last 7 tourneys. A 3rd just two years ago. Hard to believe they’re getting rid of Smith.
 
Respectfully disagree. Spent 4 years there and winter was rough from November through March. Plus the 2nd half of October and 1st half of April weren't exactly great; June to August are nice.
Grew up in PA, for reference. If you grew up in Siberia then absolutely the Finger Lakes are awesome most of the year.
And if you grew up in PA but lived in San Diego for 30 years, you wouldn’t want to live in the Finger Lakes, PA or Siberia! :cool:
 
I've spent my entire life in Pennsylvania and the last 30+ in extreme northern PA, about 2 hours from Ithaca. Didn't mind it as a young man, but I hate it now and have since moved seasonally to upstate South Carolina because the winters are so miserable "up home". Summers are delightful. Autumn is nice, November can be beautiful, even December is sometimes nice, but January, February and even March suck. April can be nice or can be cold and wet. I feel like I've got the best of both worlds now, but those who are saying there are better places to be (weather wise) than Ithaca, NY are correct from my perspective.
 
Compare placement vs Cornell even just the last decade. Cornell has been worse without the past glory.
Looking at the past decade only, I don't think I would agree. Kind of depends on how you look at it.

OK ST has outplaced Cornell 6 times in the last 10 tournaments. But OK ST has also finished in 13th place or worse 3 times (all within the last 5 years). Cornell's worst finish of the last decade was 8th.
 
Looking at the past decade only, I don't think I would agree. Kind of depends on how you look at it.

OK ST has outplaced Cornell 6 times in the last 10 tournaments. But OK ST has also finished in 13th place or worse 3 times (all within the last 5 years). Cornell's worst finish of the last decade was 8th.
This is true, but think of it like this:

What you just described is likely the best 10 year stretch Cornell can/will ever achieve. To their credit, they topped out in program capability.

What you just described is probably the worst 10 year stretch Oklahoma State could have, short of completely ignoring the sport entirely.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mcpat
This is true, but think of it like this:

What you just described is likely the best 10 year stretch Cornell can/will ever achieve. To their credit, they topped out in program capability.

What you just described is probably the worst 10 year stretch Oklahoma State could have, short of completely ignoring the sport entirely.
If you say so.

I don't there's much to indicate that, other than an assumption that OK State will be better than Cornell because OK State is a traditional wrestling school. I know who I'd pick to be better next year.

Look at Cornell's stretch right before the 2013-2023 decade. Two second place finishes, a third, and a fifth from 2009-2012. Outscored/outplaced OK State each year.
 
Compare placement vs Cornell even just the last decade. Cornell has been worse without the past glory.
Of course, there is this in 2023 (all of the Cornell vs. Oklahoma State matches):
  • Semifinal - Vito Arujau (Cornell) 25-1 won by major decision over Daton Fix (Oklahoma State) 30-2 (MD 11-3)
  • Quarterfinal - Chris Foca (Cornell) 29-2 won by fall over Dustin Plott (Oklahoma State) 25-7 (Fall 1:54)
  • Cons. Round 3 - Jacob Cardenas (Cornell) 20-6 won by decision over Luke Surber (Oklahoma State) 23-10 (Dec 12-5)
:cool:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Str8DBLz
Of course, there is this in 2023 (all of the Cornell vs. Oklahoma State matches):
  • Semifinal - Vito Arujau (Cornell) 25-1 won by major decision over Daton Fix (Oklahoma State) 30-2 (MD 11-3)
  • Quarterfinal - Chris Foca (Cornell) 29-2 won by fall over Dustin Plott (Oklahoma State) 25-7 (Fall 1:54)
  • Cons. Round 3 - Jacob Cardenas (Cornell) 20-6 won by decision over Luke Surber (Oklahoma State) 23-10 (Dec 12-5)
:cool:
So what’s your take on Grey’s hypothetical interest level in the hypothetical OK State job?
 
Looking at the past decade only, I don't think I would agree. Kind of depends on how you look at it.

OK ST has outplaced Cornell 6 times in the last 10 tournaments. But OK ST has also finished in 13th place or worse 3 times (all within the last 5 years). Cornell's worst finish of the last decade was 8th.
Here are the data going back to 2009 (first year on the PSU Wrestling Club's site).

Cornell is the girl you marry. OKST is the crazy fun girl you ditch before she becomes a life-long mistake.


CornellOKST
YearPlacePtsPlacePts
2009​
5​
73.5​
16​
34.0​
2010​
2​
90.0​
6​
65.0​
2011​
2​
93.5​
4​
70.5​
2012​
4​
102.5​
6​
66.0​
2013​
5​
65.0​
2​
119.5​
2014​
7​
53.0​
3​
96.5​
2015​
5​
71.5​
7​
66.0​
2016​
7​
67.0​
2​
97.5​
2017​
8​
60.5​
3​
103.0​
2018​
7​
48.0​
14​
37.5​
2019​
7​
59.5​
3​
84.0​
2021​
N/AN/A
3​
99.5​
2022​
7​
54.5​
14​
38.5​
2023​
3​
76.5​
19​
28.5​
Avg
5.3​
70.4​
7.3​
71.9​
High
2​
102.5​
2​
119.5​
Low
8​
48.0​
19​
28.5​
STDEV
2.1​
16.6​
5.9​
29.3​
 
Here are the data going back to 2009 (first year on the PSU Wrestling Club's site).

Cornell is the girl you marry. OKST is the crazy fun girl you ditch before she becomes a life-long mistake.


CornellOKST
YearPlacePtsPlacePts
2009​
5​
73.5​
16​
34.0​
2010​
2​
90.0​
6​
65.0​
2011​
2​
93.5​
4​
70.5​
2012​
4​
102.5​
6​
66.0​
2013​
5​
65.0​
2​
119.5​
2014​
7​
53.0​
3​
96.5​
2015​
5​
71.5​
7​
66.0​
2016​
7​
67.0​
2​
97.5​
2017​
8​
60.5​
3​
103.0​
2018​
7​
48.0​
14​
37.5​
2019​
7​
59.5​
3​
84.0​
2021​
N/AN/A
3​
99.5​
2022​
7​
54.5​
14​
38.5​
2023​
3​
76.5​
19​
28.5​
Avg
5.3​
70.4​
7.3​
71.9​
High
2​
102.5​
2​
119.5​
Low
8​
48.0​
19​
28.5​
STDEV
2.1​
16.6​
5.9​
29.3​
It’s funny because I see it kind of the opposite.

Oklahoma State is the one you settle down with. I think if you take Rob Koll and Mike Grey to Stillwater, their achievements are every but Cornell’s, plus some.
 
It’s funny because I see it kind of the opposite.

Oklahoma State is the one you settle down with. I think if you take Rob Koll and Mike Grey to Stillwater, their achievements are every but Cornell’s, plus some.
On the other hand, who of all their excellent recruits who were able to be accepted at Cornell would have turned up that opportunity and gone to Oklahoma State?
 
  • Like
Reactions: donboy6499
On the other hand, who of all their excellent recruits who were able to be accepted at Cornell would have turned up that opportunity and gone to Oklahoma State?
Oh I think there are kids that have turned down Cornell for Okie State/Iowa/PSU/etc.

Corollary to this would be, how many team titles might Koll have won if he could have gotten in every wrestler he wanted without pesky standards?
 
I've spent my entire life in Pennsylvania and the last 30+ in extreme northern PA, about 2 hours from Ithaca. Didn't mind it as a young man, but I hate it now and have since moved seasonally to upstate South Carolina because the winters are so miserable "up home". Summers are delightful. Autumn is nice, November can be beautiful, even December is sometimes nice, but January, February and even March suck. April can be nice or can be cold and wet. I feel like I've got the best of both worlds now, but those who are saying there are better places to be (weather wise) than Ithaca, NY are correct from my perspective.
As my oldest granddaughter said to me when she was about 5, "gee Pap, if it weren't for Christmas and wrestling winter would be totally useless."
 
I think the redshirt vs greyshirt issue isn’t getting enough attention. Come to OkSt. Live on campus. Take classes. Attend regular practices. Wrestle in a few duals. Graduate on time. Start on your masters 5th year.

Vs waste a year of your life. :) And wrestle with the club.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT